Lesley Manville Is Blasted as ‘Out of Touch’ and ‘Pretentious’ for Claiming Theatre-Goers Are ‘Insulting’ Actors by Taking Photos During Curtain Call
Lesley Manville, the acclaimed two-time Olivier Award-winning actress, has recently ignited a heated discussion within the theatre community. Her comments about audience members taking photos during curtain calls have sparked backlash, with many labeling her views as “out of touch” and “pretentious.” Manville criticized the growing trend of theatre-goers capturing moments on their phones during performances and curtain calls, describing it as an insult to the actors and the art form itself.
Currently starring at the National Theatre alongside Aidan Turner in the latest adaptation of *Les Liaisons Dangereuses*, Manville has been vocal about her frustration with the intrusion of digital devices into live theatre. This article delves into the controversy, examining the reasons behind Manville’s stance, the audience’s response, and the broader implications for the future of theatre.
Lesley Manville’s Criticism of Theatre-Goers Taking Photos During Curtain Calls
Lesley Manville recently spoke out on BBC Radio 4 about the increasing habit of theatre audiences taking photos during curtain calls. She described this practice as “insulting” to actors, urging theatre-goers to “let it live in their souls for five minutes” instead of reaching for their phones. According to Manville, this trend has only recently become prevalent in the West End, having been imported from the United States where it is more common.
Manville emphasized the importance of preserving the magic and intimacy of live theatre by minimizing digital distractions. She revealed that her current production has banned photography both during the show and at the curtain call to protect the experience for both performers and audiences. The actress lamented the shift in audience behavior, noting that when she performed on Broadway in *Oedipus*, nearly everyone would take out their phones at the end of the evening, which she found disheartening.
Her comments reflect a broader concern among theatre professionals about how smartphones and social media are changing the way audiences engage with live performances. Many actors and directors argue that the presence of phones disrupts the atmosphere and diminishes the emotional connection between performers and viewers.
The Audience’s Reaction and the Debate Over Digital Etiquette in Theatre
Manville’s remarks have not been universally well-received. Many theatre-goers and social media users have pushed back against her viewpoint, accusing her of being “out of touch” with modern audience habits. Critics argue that taking photos is a way for fans to capture memories and share their theatre experiences with friends and followers online, which can actually help promote the art form to a wider audience.
Some have described Manville’s stance as “pretentious,” suggesting that it places undue restrictions on audience enjoyment and fails to recognize how technology has become an integral part of everyday life. Others contend that the theatre industry needs to adapt to changing times rather than trying to enforce outdated norms.
This debate highlights a growing tension between tradition and innovation in the performing arts. While many agree that phones can be distracting, there is also recognition that digital engagement can enhance accessibility and interest in theatre, especially among younger generations.
Balancing Tradition and Technology: The Future of Theatre Etiquette
The controversy surrounding Lesley Manville’s comments underscores a larger conversation about how live theatre can coexist with modern technology. Some theatres have introduced policies banning photography and phone use during performances to preserve the sanctity of the live experience. Others have embraced technology by encouraging audiences to share their experiences on social media, sometimes even incorporating live tweeting or interactive elements into shows.
Finding a balance is crucial. Theatre professionals want to maintain the emotional intensity and immediacy that make live performances unique, while also recognizing that digital tools can help attract new audiences and keep the art form relevant.
Educational campaigns about digital etiquette in theatres are becoming more common, aiming to inform audiences about when and how phone use is appropriate. Some productions provide designated moments for photos or social media sharing, allowing fans to capture memories without disrupting the performance.
Conclusion: Preserving the Magic of Live Theatre in a Digital Age
Lesley Manville’s criticism of theatre-goers taking photos during curtain calls has sparked an important debate about respect, tradition, and the role of technology in live performances. While her comments have been met with both support and backlash, they highlight the need for a thoughtful approach to digital etiquette in theatres.
As audiences and performers navigate this evolving landscape, it’s essential to find ways to honor the unique, ephemeral nature of live theatre while embracing the benefits of modern technology. Whether you’re a theatre lover or a performer, consider how your actions impact the shared experience on stage.
If you’re passionate about live theatre, join the conversation and help promote respectful audience behavior that preserves the magic of every performance. Share your thoughts and experiences on social media using #TheatreEtiquette and support productions that value both tradition and innovation.
