Pope Francis has now spent more than two weeks in the hospital, marking the longest stay
of his papacy. The Vatican has continued to provide updates on his condition, reporting slow but steady progress as he recovers from severe bronchitis and double pneumonia. Despite these assurances, speculation has been running rampant, with rumors circulating about the
possibility of his resignation. The Vatican, however, has not suggested any such scenario,
and those close to the pope insist that he remains committed to his role as the leader of the Catholic Church.
Among those dismissing the resignation rumors is papal historian, author, and biographer Austen Ivereigh. He points to Pope Francis’ own statements regarding his commitment to serving for life. Although the pontiff wrote a secret letter of resignation at the beginning of his tenure in case of severe incapacity, Ivereigh maintains that Pope Francis does not view the papacy as a position one can simply step away from.
“He’s spoken various times about this,” Ivereigh explained in an interview with Fox News. “He’s saying that for him, the papacy is for life.” He went on to argue that, in today’s world, which often prioritizes youth and physical strength, the idea of lifelong service holds even greater significance. “It’s really important in a world where there’s a kind of cult of health and youth that we say, ‘No, there is a mission that God gives you, which is for life.’”
Millions of Catholics around the world have been praying for the 88-year-old pontiff’s recovery. In St. Peter’s Square, a nightly rosary vigil led by a cardinal has brought the faithful together in prayer, hoping for Pope Francis to regain his strength and continue his mission. Despite his health struggles, many remain optimistic that he will pull through.
Ivereigh, the author of The Great Reformer: Francis and the Making of a Radical Pope and other books on the papacy, believes that Francis will recover. While he acknowledges that the pope may emerge from this illness physically weaker, he argues that his spiritual leadership remains as strong as ever. Yet, even he admits that a sense of uncertainty looms over the Vatican. “There’s an anxiety. There’s a sense of uncertainty,” he acknowledged.
That uncertainty is compounded by historical precedent. Pope Francis’ predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI, shocked the world when he resigned in 2013, becoming the first pontiff to step down in more than 500 years. Given that history, there is lingering speculation that Francis could follow suit, especially as his health continues to decline. However, others believe that even if the pope does not intend to resign, the question of succession is still looming large.
Within the Church, conversations about the next conclave are already taking place, even if they remain largely behind closed doors. Some factions are preparing for the inevitable moment when the College of Cardinals will gather in Rome to elect the next successor to St. Peter. Not all voices within the Church are unified in their opinions about what should come next.
Bishop Joseph Strickland, a well-known critic of Pope Francis, recently published an open letter to the College of Cardinals, urging them to choose wisely when the time comes for the next papal election. In his strongly worded letter, Strickland expressed deep concern about the direction of the Church and warned against electing a candidate who, in his view, would be unfit for the role.
“As the conclave approaches, I feel bound in conscience to share my deep concern – which I know is shared by many bishops, clergy, and members of the lay faithful – that this conclave will attempt the election of a man ineligible to hold the office of pope,” Strickland wrote. He went further, cautioning the cardinals about their moral responsibility, stating, “You have a grave obligation before God to refuse to give assent to the election of any candidate who does not fulfill the conditions established by divine law.”
His letter contained thinly veiled accusations directed at Pope Francis himself. Many of the pope’s critics have accused him of not always adhering strictly to traditional theological principles. Strickland made his stance clear by writing, “If a public heretic, or a man who is reasonably suspected of being a public heretic, receives sufficient votes, faithful cardinals have an obligation to refuse to accept the validity of his election.”
Despite such criticisms, Ivereigh offers a starkly different perspective on Francis’ leadership. He argues that the pope is deeply in line with the teachings of Jesus and that his approach to faith combines doctrinal truth with an emphasis on compassion and love.
“He proclaims the truth, and at the same time he heals and loves,” Ivereigh stated. “And in fact, the truth that he proclaims is a healing truth, and the healing that he does—it communicates the truth of who God is.”
As Pope Francis continues his recovery in the hospital, the broader Catholic Church remains in a state of watchful anticipation. Whether he continues to lead for years to come or whether his health forces an eventual transition, his impact on the Church is undeniable. For now, the prayers of millions continue, and the Vatican remains steadfast in its message: the pope is improving, and his mission is far from over.
Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.